While chicken poaches, hard-boil your eggs (12 minutes in boiling water, then an ice bath). Peel and separate yolks from whites.
When Mittie’s finally closed its doors in the early 2010s (after a long decline and a change in ownership), the city mourned. Dozens of articles appeared in the Courier-Journal and local blogs, all asking the same question: Where can we get the recipe? What made Mittie’s chicken salad so distinctive? Let’s break down the attributes that set it apart from every other deli scoop or church cookbook version. mittie-s tea room chicken salad recipe
By the 1950s, the line stretched out the door. Men began sneaking in for lunch, though the décor remained unapologetically feminine. Mittie’s became a rite of passage—a place for bridal showers, birthday luncheons, and mother-daughter outings. And through it all, the chicken salad recipe remained a closely guarded secret. While chicken poaches, hard-boil your eggs (12 minutes
Celery is standard, but Mittie’s minced it almost to a brunoise—tiny, uniform cubes. This gave a delicate crunch without the aggressive, vegetal bite that can overwhelm. Some former employees have hinted that the celery was briefly soaked in ice water to crisp it further before mincing. Dozens of articles appeared in the Courier-Journal and
In the pantheon of Southern comfort food, certain dishes transcend mere sustenance to become cultural touchstones. The pimiento cheese sandwich at the Masters Tournament. The congealed salad at a Delta bridal luncheon. And, for those who ever had the privilege of pulling up a lace-draped chair at Mittie’s Tea Room in Louisville, Kentucky, the chicken salad.
In a medium bowl, combine mayonnaise, drained relish, minced onion, sugar, celery salt, almond extract, and white pepper. Mash the hard-boiled egg yolks into this mixture with a fork until smooth and pale yellow. Set aside.
Cover and refrigerate for at least 4 hours, but ideally 24 hours. Mittie’s always made her chicken salad the day before service. The flavors need time to marry, and the almond extract will mellow from “perfume” to “what is that lovely note?”